HAiV3 Official Response
⚠ Misinformation Response
Setting the Record Straight on Hive (HAiV3)
Two published articles — one on BehindMLM, one on Jesse Singh’s Millionaire Drive Blog — contain factual errors, unverified speculation, and undisclosed conflicts of interest about this platform. This page documents the truth, with evidence.
Published by: Clifford Williams, Founder — Hive (HAiV3) / HEXucation
Platform founded: 2022
Last updated: May 2026
The Reviewers
Who Wrote These Articles — and Why It Matters
Before addressing the claims, it is worth understanding who made them and what their incentives are. Both reviewers have significant conflicts of interest they did not disclose.
BehindMLM — “Oz”
Anonymous blogger, est. 2009
BehindMLM’s author operates under the pseudonym “Oz” and has never publicly confirmed their real identity — the same standard they hold against the platforms they review. The site is funded entirely by Google AdSense advertising. More alarming articles generate more traffic; more traffic generates more revenue.
Oz’s review methodology is pattern-matching: any platform with a referral commission structure plus crypto content is categorised as a pyramid scheme using the same template. No product testing, no direct contact with the founder, no attempt at verification before publishing.
In the HEXucation review, Oz stated: “Clifford Williams doesn’t exist.” This is demonstrably false. Clifford Williams is named in the footer of haiv3.com as “Abundance Thinker,” appears in publicly available video content, and has been personally contactable through Telegram since the platform launched in 2022 — as confirmed by actual students.
⚠ Undisclosed Conflict
BehindMLM earns advertising revenue from high-traffic fear-based content. Labelling legitimate platforms as scams is financially incentivised — the more alarming the headline, the more clicks, the more ad revenue.
Jesse Singh — “The Millionaire Drive”
Affiliate Marketer — themillionairedriveblog.com / u/milldrive on Reddit
Jesse Singh publishes “scam reviews” on his blog and reposts them to Reddit under the account u/milldrive. His review of Hive is not journalism — it is an affiliate advertisement. Every negative claim about this platform is a setup for his CTA: a link to a competing programme with the tracking code affid=7&sub1=TMDHive embedded in the URL.
Singh’s history is documented. He was one of the top earners in Digital Altitude, a programme shut down by the US Federal Trade Commission in 2018 for fraud. He pivoted overnight to the next programme and has repeated this cycle ever since. He earns money by discrediting alternatives to whatever he is currently promoting.
⚠ Direct Financial Conflict — Not Disclosed
Singh’s article contains three calls to action linking to discoverprimedefi.com with his personal affiliate ID embedded. He earns a commission for every person who clicks through. This was not disclosed anywhere in the article. The “review” is an advertisement.
The Facts
Every Major Claim — Corrected
Both articles repeat the same core allegations. Here is each one, alongside the documented reality.
❌ False Claim #1
“Hive has no retailable products or services. Just membership.”
✓ The Reality
HAiV3 offers 13 courses comprising 216 lessons of cryptocurrency and blockchain education — publicly accessible and purchasable without any recruitment or referral requirement. HEXucation, its predecessor, had 2 courses and 27 lessons. The curriculum has grown ninefold. Anyone can visit haiv3.com and purchase a course without recruiting a single person. That is the definition of a retailable product.
❌ False Claim #2
“No transparency on who runs the company. No CEO, no founder, no team page. Nothing.”
✓ The Reality
The founder is Clifford Williams, operating under the brand name “Abundance Thinker,” which appears in the footer of every page on haiv3.com. Clifford has been directly contactable through the platform’s Telegram community since 2022. Students have spoken with him on personal calls. He appears in videos associated with the platform. The BehindMLM author literally stated “Clifford Williams doesn’t exist” — yet offered zero evidence for this claim beyond his own inability to find the information.
❌ False Claim #3
“Hexucation collapsed in 2024. Hive is just the same failed scheme rebooted.”
✓ The Reality
HEXucation’s website was taken offline in 2025 because a third party committed copyright infringement. The infringer registered hexucation.org — a domain deliberately chosen to impersonate the original — and copied significant portions of HEXucation’s site content and course material. After stripping most of the course content while retaining elements of the site design, the same operators rebranded hexucation.org to unitasrise.org. The platform did not “collapse” due to financial failure or a Ponzi-style implosion. There were zero student complaints, zero outstanding payment disputes, and zero regulatory actions against HEXucation or its founder. The rebrand to Hive (HAiV3) happened to protect students from confusion with the fraudulent copycat and to expand the platform’s scope beyond HEX-specific education to a broader AI, blockchain, Crypto, Marketing, Digital Marketing, FinTech & Entrepreneurship curriculum.
❌ False Claim #4
“The old Hexucation domain redirects to Hive — proof the same scammers are behind both.”
✓ The Reality
The domain redirect exists because the same founder owns both domains. This is standard practice for any rebrand. When a business changes its name, it redirects its old domain to the new one so existing students and search traffic are not lost. This is evidence of continuity and transparency — not concealment. BehindMLM’s logic would flag every legitimate rebrand in history as suspicious.
❌ False Claim #5
“HEXucation was designed to push worthless HEX tokens onto affiliates. HEX is a collapsed Ponzi. Stay far away.”
✓ The Reality
BehindMLM’s author explicitly wrote “If I had to guess…” — then published that speculation as established fact. Yes, HEXucation taught about the HEX token and PulseChain ecosystem. That is what the name refers to. Teaching about an asset is not the same as running a scheme to offload it.
More critically: both BehindMLM and Jesse Singh state that the SEC sued Richard Heart (Schueler) for fraud and that HEX is a collapsed Ponzi. What they do not tell you — because it undermines their narrative — is that the SEC’s case against Richard Heart was dismissed in March 2025. A US federal judge ruled the SEC had failed to prove its claims. Neither reviewer updated their articles to reflect this. They continue to cite a lawsuit that no longer exists as evidence of fraud.
HEXucation provided education about HEX and PulseChain the same way a course platform might teach about any cryptocurrency. No HEX tokens were sold through the platform. No student was required to hold HEX. The current Hive (HAiV3) platform does not focus on HEX — the curriculum has expanded to cover AI, broader DeFi, trading strategy, and SEO.
❌ False Claim #6 — Singh Specific
“haiv3.com — Registered August 2025. Privately registered. Just a domain and a dream.”
✓ The Reality
Singh presents a 2025 domain registration date as evidence this is a fly-by-night operation with no history. This is deliberately misleading. HEXucation was founded in 2022 — the platform has a four-year operational history. haiv3.com was registered in 2025 specifically because HEXucation rebranded following the copyright infringement attack on the original domain. The new domain date reflects a rebrand, not a new scheme. The community, the students, the courses, and the founder all carried over directly.
Domain privacy protection is used by millions of legitimate businesses worldwide — including Singh’s own properties — to prevent spam and protect personal information. It is not evidence of anything.
The Actual Products
What HAiV3 Actually Sells
Both articles claimed this platform has “no products.” Here is the course catalogue — published, purchasable, and available to any visitor without requiring recruitment or referral.
| Tier | Price | Content | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Meta Learning | Free | 1 course · 5 lessons | Public |
| Beginner | $2 | 2 courses · 72 lessons | Retail |
| Intermediate | $12 | 3 courses · 59 lessons | Retail |
| Advanced | $55 | 7 courses · 80 lessons | Retail |
| All Inclusive | $69 | 13 courses · 216 lessons | Retail |
| AI for Market Awareness | $249/yr | Trading signals & AI decision tools | Retail |
Note on affiliate commissions: HAiV3 pays course sale commissions of 50% (level 1), 10% (level 2), and 20% (level 3). These commissions are paid on the sale of real courses to real students — not on recruitment fees paid to join. This is functionally identical to how platforms like Teachable, Kajabi, and Udemy operate with affiliate programmes. The courses are the product.
Platform History
The Actual Timeline
Both articles misrepresent the platform’s history. Here is what actually happened.
2022
HEXucation Launched
Clifford Williams launches HEXucation — a cryptocurrency and blockchain education platform focused on HEX and the PulseChain ecosystem, with an affiliate programme. Domain registered. Community built on Telegram.
2024
Web3 Payment Integration
Platform upgraded to accept cryptocurrency payments directly. Course library updated significantly. Student base grows internationally.
Jul 2024
BehindMLM Publishes HEXucation Review
BehindMLM publishes “Hexucation Review: The future of MLM pyramid scheme” at behindmlm.com/mlm-reviews/hexucation-review-the-future-of-mlm-pyramid-scheme/. The review calls the platform a pyramid scheme based on its commission structure and dismisses the course content as worthless — without testing a single lesson or contacting the founder. In the comments, when a student defends the platform, the anonymous author “Oz” responds: “Clifford Williams doesn’t exist.” This is a statement of fact about a real, named, living person — made with zero evidence by an author who refuses to reveal their own identity.
2025
Copyright Infringement Attack
A third party registers hexucation.org — deliberately imitating the original domain — and copies HEXucation’s site content and course material. After stripping most course content, the operators rebrand hexucation.org to unitasrise.org, retaining stolen site elements. To protect students from confusion with this fraudulent copycat, Clifford Williams rebrands to Hive (HAiV3 — HEXucation A.i. V3).
2025
Platform Expansion — haiv3.com Registered
haiv3.com launches with 13 courses, 216 lessons, HiveFlash (DeFi arbitrage), HiveClix (CPC ad network), HiveXTrade (AI trading signals), HiveEO (AI citation tool), and Buzz AI (WordPress content tool). Multiple independent revenue streams — not a single recruitment loop.
Apr 2026
Singh Article + BehindMLM Hive Review
BehindMLM publishes a follow-up titled “Hive Review: Hexucation scammers try again” — carrying the same false narrative to the rebranded platform. Jesse Singh publishes an identical-framing article on themillionairedriveblog.com and reposts it to Reddit as u/milldrive, embedding his personal affiliate tracking link (affid=7&sub1=TMDHive) throughout — earning a commission on every reader diverted to his competing offer. Neither article was updated to reflect the March 2025 dismissal of the SEC case against Richard Heart.
The Irony
What Jesse Singh Is Actually Promoting
Singh’s article condemns this platform for its affiliate commission structure — then promotes his own alternative with a commission-based affiliate link embedded throughout the article.
Singh’s Affiliate Link — Embedded in the “Review”
Every call to action in Singh’s article points to:https://discoverprimedefi.com/seehow?uid=34&oid=7&affid=7&sub1=TMDHive
The parameter affid=7 is Singh’s affiliate ID. The parameter sub1=TMDHive is his tracking tag confirming this traffic came from his Hive review. He earns a commission on every signup. This was not disclosed anywhere in his article.
His promoted alternative promises “3% to 10% per month” returns. By his own logic — applied consistently — that would make his recommendation far more deserving of a “Ponzi” label than a $2 crypto education course.
Singh’s Track Record — Documented
Singh was a top earner in Digital Altitude, which the US Federal Trade Commission shut down in 2018 for fraud. He promoted the scheme, recruited participants, earned significant commissions, and walked away without consequence when the FTC acted. He then pivoted immediately to the next programme.
His business model: publish “scam reviews” of competitors, funnel readers to whatever he is currently being paid to promote, repeat. He has done this across dozens of platforms over many years.
BehindMLM itself has documented Singh’s history of plagiarising content and promoting fraudulent MLM schemes.
In Summary
What This Is Actually About
Neither BehindMLM nor Jesse Singh contacted the founder before publishing. Neither reviewed the course content. Neither disclosed their conflicts of interest. Neither corrected their articles when students provided factual rebuttals in the comments.
One operates an anonymous ad-funded blog and financially benefits from alarming headlines. The other runs a review site designed to funnel readers to competing affiliate offers. Both used this platform — a real educational product built by a real founder over three years — as content fodder.
The truth is documented above. The platform exists. The courses exist. The founder exists. The students exist. Any prospective student is welcome to verify this directly.
See the Platform for Yourself
Don’t take anyone’s word for it — not ours, not theirs. Explore the actual courses, tools, and community.
FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)
What is Hive (HAiV3)?
Hive (HAiV3 — HEXucation A.i. V3) is a cryptocurrency and blockchain education platform founded in 2022 by Clifford Williams. It offers 13 courses and 216 lessons covering beginner through advanced blockchain, Cryptocurrency, DeFi, AI, Marketing, Digital Marketing, FinTech and Entrepreneurship topics, alongside independent tools including HiveClix (CPC ad network), HiveXTrade (Educational AI trading signals), HiveEO (AI citation tool), and Buzz AI (WordPress content tool).
Where can I find information about Hive (HAiV3)?
The official platform is haiv3.com. The founder Clifford Williams is named in the footer of every page under the brand name “Abundance Thinker” and has been contactable through the platform’s Telegram community since 2022.
What is the purpose of this blog post?
This page was published by the founder of HAiV3 to correct factual errors in two articles — one published on BehindMLM and one on Jesse Singh’s Millionaire Drive Blog — both of which made demonstrably false claims about the platform, its founder, and its history.
Is Hive (HAiV3.com) a scam?
No. Hive (HAiV3.com) is a legitimate cryptocurrency and blockchain education platform founded in 2022 by Clifford Williams. It has a four-year operational history, 13 purchasable courses comprising 216 lessons, and multiple independent tools including HiveFlash, HiveClix, HiveXTrade, and HiveEO. There have been zero regulatory actions, zero student complaints, and no financial collapse. The platform rebranded from HEXucation to Hive (HAiV3) in 2025 following a copyright infringement attack by a third party who cloned the site at hexucation.org before rebranding to unitasrise.org.
Who is behind Hive (HAiV3)?
Hive (HAiV3) was founded by Clifford Williams, who operates under the brand name “Abundance Thinker.” His name appears in the footer of every page on haiv3.com. He has been directly contactable through the platform’s Telegram community since the platform launched as HEXucation in 2022, and appears in videos associated with the platform. The claim made by BehindMLM in July 2024 that “Clifford Williams doesn’t exist” is demonstrably false — it was a statement of fact about a real, named, living person, made by an anonymous author who refuses to reveal their own identity.
Did HEXucation collapse?
No. HEXucation did not collapse due to financial failure. The site was taken offline in 2025 after a third party committed copyright infringement — registering hexucation.org to impersonate the original platform and copying its course content and site design. The operators of that fraudulent site later rebranded it to unitasrise.org. To protect students from confusion with the copycat, the founder rebranded the legitimate platform to Hive (HAiV3 — HEXucation A.i. V3). There were no outstanding payment disputes and no regulatory actions.
Is Hive (HAiV3) a pyramid scheme?
No. Hive (HAiV3) sells real educational courses that any member of the public can purchase without recruiting anyone. Its catalogue includes 13 courses and 216 lessons across beginner, intermediate, and advanced cryptocurrency and blockchain education. Affiliate commissions are paid on course sales — not on recruitment fees. This is the same model used by mainstream course platforms with affiliate programmes. BehindMLM applied a pyramid scheme label based solely on the existence of a referral commission structure, without reviewing the course content or contacting the founder.
Why did HEXucation rebrand to Hive (HAiV3)?
The rebrand from HEXucation to Hive (HAiV3 — HEXucation A.i. V3) happened in 2025 for two reasons. First, a third party had created a fraudulent lookalike site at hexucation.org that was causing confusion among students; distancing the brand from that copycat was essential. Second, the platform had expanded significantly beyond its original HEX and PulseChain focus to include AI tools, broader DeFi education, educational trading signals, SEO tools, and a CPC advertising network — making the original name too narrow for what the platform had become.
What does Jesse Singh’s Reddit post and Millionaire Drive Blog say about Hive, and is it accurate?
Jesse Singh published a review of Hive on Reddit and themillionairedriveblog.com claiming it has no real products, no identifiable founder, and is a recycled pyramid scheme. Every major claim is factually incorrect. Critically, Singh embedded his personal affiliate tracking link — containing the parameters affid=7 and sub1=TMDHive — in every call to action, earning a commission on every reader he diverted to a competing offer. This conflict of interest was not disclosed anywhere in the article. Singh was previously a top earner in Digital Altitude, a programme shut down by the US Federal Trade Commission in 2018 for fraud. His business model is to publish negative “reviews” of competing platforms and funnel readers to whatever he is currently being paid to promote.
What happened with the SEC case against Richard Heart and HEX?
The SEC sued Richard Heart (Schueler) in 2023 alleging fraud related to the HEX token. Both BehindMLM and Jesse Singh cited this lawsuit as evidence that HEX — and by association HEXucation — were fraudulent. What neither reviewer disclosed is that the SEC’s case against Richard Heart was dismissed by a US federal judge in March 2025, who ruled the SEC had failed to prove its claims. Neither article was updated to reflect this outcome. They continue to reference a dismissed lawsuit as active evidence of fraud. HEXucation taught about HEX and PulseChain as part of its cryptocurrency curriculum — the same way any education platform covers any asset class. No HEX tokens were sold through the platform and no student was required to hold them.
© 2026 HAiV3 / HEXucation A.i. V3 · Founded by Clifford Williams · haiv3.com
This page was published in response to factually inaccurate articles on behindmlm.com and themillionairedriveblog.com. All claims made on this page are documented and verifiable.